Too personal to be pertinent
I like to sample works by the winners of the Nobel Prize in Literature—the novelists and playwrights, not the poets—in hopes of discovering an author I’ll really like. American author Saul Bellow won the Nobel in 1976. Not knowing much about him or his work, I decided to go with one of his best-selling and most critically acclaimed novels. Herzog, published in 1964, won the National Book Award, the Prix International, and was named by Time magazine as one of the one hundred best English-language novels of the last century.
Moses Herzog is a college professor in New York, though currently unemployed. His area of expertise is Romantic literature. He was born in Montreal to Russian-Jewish immigrant parents, and he partially grew up in Chicago, where his father made an illegal living as a bootlegger. Herzog has been married twice and has two children, one from each marriage. His second wife, Madeleine, has just ended their relationship by running off with Herzog’s best friend. The character of Herzog is largely autobiographical; most of the preceding details apply to Bellow’s life as well. As the novel opens, we find Herzog roughing it in a somewhat dilapidated country house in the Berkshires of Massachusetts. His mental and emotional stability has taken a major hit from his wife’s recent betrayal. The rest of the book is a series of flashbacks revealing Herzog’s prior life and what happened to bring him to where we find him now. One of Herzog’s nervous habits is to constantly jot down notes and write letters that he never sends—letters to family, friends, and famous people alive or dead. This amounts to a rather gimmicky device for Bellow to indulge in passages of first-person stream-of-consciousness writing that augment the main third-person narrative.
Throughout the book, Herzog obsesses over his breakup with the cold, calculating, and cheating Madeleine. It’s hard to feel sorry for the guy, however, when he’s had a string of mistresses himself, one of whom is still in the picture and happens to be gorgeous, nice, and worships the ground he walks on. It’s like a rich people problem or a white people problem. Quit bitching and get over it. Is there a message to all of this? Perhaps in the final chapter. Until then, there seems to be a different message in each paragraph as Herzog mentally pontificates on various issues.
Moses Herzog is a college professor in New York, though currently unemployed. His area of expertise is Romantic literature. He was born in Montreal to Russian-Jewish immigrant parents, and he partially grew up in Chicago, where his father made an illegal living as a bootlegger. Herzog has been married twice and has two children, one from each marriage. His second wife, Madeleine, has just ended their relationship by running off with Herzog’s best friend. The character of Herzog is largely autobiographical; most of the preceding details apply to Bellow’s life as well. As the novel opens, we find Herzog roughing it in a somewhat dilapidated country house in the Berkshires of Massachusetts. His mental and emotional stability has taken a major hit from his wife’s recent betrayal. The rest of the book is a series of flashbacks revealing Herzog’s prior life and what happened to bring him to where we find him now. One of Herzog’s nervous habits is to constantly jot down notes and write letters that he never sends—letters to family, friends, and famous people alive or dead. This amounts to a rather gimmicky device for Bellow to indulge in passages of first-person stream-of-consciousness writing that augment the main third-person narrative.
Herzog was published a little before my time, but I did grow up in the 1970s. This novel reminds me of many a movie from that era, romantic relationship dramas that might have starred Elliott Gould, Dustin Hoffman, or Alan Alda. In the late ‘60s and ‘70s, people who could afford it were obsessed with psychotherapy, and that New Agey self-involvement certainly comes across in this book. It sometimes seems to me like late 20th-century American fiction was mostly a competition to see who could create the most realistic human being, with all the psychological complexity that entails. What that character actually does, or what happens to him or her, often feels like an afterthought. Such is the case with Herzog. What we’re expected to marvel at, and what the critics of his day ate up, was the level of detail in Herzog’s back story and the breadth and candidness of his interior thoughts. Bellow has certainly done a skillful job of rendering such details. The specificity and quirkiness with which he draws Herzog, however, makes the character difficult to identify with, unless you happen to be a Jewish intellectual who’s recently undergone a hostile divorce. They say write what you know, but here autobiographical excesses keep Herzog from being the middle-aged everyman, the Babbitt of his generation, that Bellow probably intended.
Throughout the book, Herzog obsesses over his breakup with the cold, calculating, and cheating Madeleine. It’s hard to feel sorry for the guy, however, when he’s had a string of mistresses himself, one of whom is still in the picture and happens to be gorgeous, nice, and worships the ground he walks on. It’s like a rich people problem or a white people problem. Quit bitching and get over it. Is there a message to all of this? Perhaps in the final chapter. Until then, there seems to be a different message in each paragraph as Herzog mentally pontificates on various issues.
There’s certainly nothing glaringly wrong with Herzog. Compared to other critical-darling novels by Nobel laureates, it’s not creepy or off-putting like Gunter Grass’s The Tin Drum or Elias Canetti’s Auto-da-Fé. Through today’s eyes, Herzog is just kind of boring and comes across as dated. For a popular bestseller of the 1960s, this was probably very good for its time, but it’s not what you would call a timeless classic. A lot of what Bellow and Herzog were concerned with in this book just doesn’t feel very relevant anymore.










